### Critical Review: Is Employee Engagement Being Reinvented—or Merely Repackaged? Review of Krish Shankar's article, published October 19, 2026 Article: [Getting your workforce fully engaged and motivated so they give their best](https://www.thecrossmentors.com/post/getting-your-workforce-fully-engaged-and-motivated-so-they-give-their-best?utm_source=chatgpt.com) Your concern is well-founded. Krish Shankar brings together several legitimate ideas from organisational psychology, motivation theory, positive psychology and leadership development. However, the article does not convincingly integrate them into a distinct, testable model of employee engagement. Its strongest contribution is the proposed emotions lens: managers should think not only about the workplace conditions they create but also about the emotions those conditions evoke. Its greatest weakness is that it treats engagement drivers, psychological mechanisms, employee experiences and organisational outcomes almost inter...